• 0 Posts
  • 80 Comments
Joined 1 year ago
cake
Cake day: July 5th, 2023

help-circle


  • Graylitic@lemm.eetoMemes@lemmy.mlCommon Marx W
    link
    fedilink
    arrow-up
    1
    ·
    1 year ago

    Is it twisting into knots to acknowledge that Marx was a human, and not a wizard? Marx wasn’t a prophet, but he was a damn good analyst and predicted tons of things correctly, such as his analysis of Capitalism. You would have a point if issues like rising disparity, rampant consumerism infecting every inch of people’s lives, stagnating wages with respect to productivity, and more happen to prove him exactly correct.

    Again, you haven’t read Marx. You just take the intellectual high road and dodge when confronted.








  • Graylitic@lemm.eetoMemes@lemmy.mlCommon Marx W
    link
    fedilink
    arrow-up
    3
    ·
    1 year ago

    Marx couldn’t have predicted the computer revolution, but absolutley predicted how Capital might react to suppress revolution. The US is well past the point at which revolution would have naturally occurred, but because of factionalism, Imperialism, and other methods by which the interests of the Proletariat have been veiled from them have caused Capitalism’s natural death to take on a form of hospice care. Computers managed to bring about revitalization in Capital, only now is it increasingly becoming worse as Capital gains more fuel to entrench itself.

    If you seriously think Marx wrote his conclusions before writing, you haven’t read Marx, full-stop.



  • -Sets up problematic hypothetical that people are not in fact advocating for

    -Destroy strawman

    Wow, you’re so good at arguing and abstraction!

    Sarcasm aside, you’re wrong about everything, from your weird council thing to the idea that demand can’t be predicted before price markers. Central Planning is not at all like what you’ve painted it as. The USSR managed constant growth even with planning by hand, in the age of computers where Amazon and Walmart predict demand before it appears this isn’t an issue.

    You have a lot of history to dig through, as well as logistics, before you make such a terribly ignorant statement like that.


  • Yea, that’s not at all what has happened historically. Democratic, Capitalist countries have killed millions of civilians with the audacity to challenge their extremist views too, does that mean they are as bad as fascism? Fuck no. Equating Communism to fascism is fascist apologia, because historically Communists have not been nearly as bad as fascists.


  • It doesn’t matter where I live, Communism is the standard for the left in a global scale. Marxism is the foundation of the left, and Communism is the ideology of Marxists. Unless you’re horribly confused and mean to refer to the Overton Window, left and right don’t change based on location.

    All in all I think you’re confusing left and right with the Overton Window.



  • Graylitic@lemm.eetoMemes@lemmy.mlRemember me comrades!
    link
    fedilink
    arrow-up
    1
    arrow-down
    1
    ·
    1 year ago

    I absolutely can, that’s a horribly bad-faith interpretation of my point. Personalities among Communists and fascists are completely different, and if you have touched grass you would know that. Unless you’re so privileged you’ve never had to care, of course.




  • Socialism isn’t welfare.

    Hundreds of Millions have died under tyrannical Capitalism built on the sentiment you’re expressing here. No Communist wants to hold people down, they want to build people up. It’s Capitalists that want to hold people down, as without doing so the bourgeoisie would not exist.